ACDN - Action of Citizens for Nuclear Disarmament
logo ACDN banniere ACDNVisiter ACDN
Accueil-Home ACDN Contact ACDN Consulter le plan du site - SiteMap Other Version
vous etes ici Homepage > News > News Articles > For a Middle East without Weapons of Mass Destruction
ACDN, What is it ?

News
Communiqués
External sources
Letters from ACDN
News Articles

Actions
2nd RID-NBC
3rd RID-NBC
Campaign "The Very Last Atom!"
Gathering for a Livable World

Petitions

Correspondance
International

Medias

Background papers

EUROPE

French Elections
News of the Presidential Campaign

10 December
For a Middle East without Weapons of Mass Destruction
by Michel Rocard, Yehuda Atai and Jean-Marie Matagne


Published 10 December 2009

Today the US President Barack Obama receives the Nobel Peace Prize which he was awarded on 13 October - nearly two months before he decided to send more troops to Afghanistan in the hope of "winning the war" that he inherited there. Let us briefly look back over the steps that earned him this Nobel Prize.

Elected on 4 November 2008, President Obama took office on 20 January. On 5 April he gave a speech in Prague calling for the abolition of nuclear weapons, and immediately US diplomats opened negotiations with Russia with a view to replacing the START Treaty on reducing nuclear weapons, which will lapse on 5 December, with an even more ambitious disarmament treaty. On 4 June in Cairo, Barack Obama delivered a great speech of openness towards the Muslim world. Then, on 25 September, he chaired a special session of the UN Security Council during which 14 heads of state or of government (plus one ambassador, from Libya) unanimously adopted a resolution of US origin promising us "a world without nuclear weapons".

On December 4, the Russian and US negotiators did not succeed in setting up a new treaty, but their presidents, Obama and Medvedev, put out a communiqué reaffirming their determination to achieve one, and to keep working "in the spirit of the START Treaty", despite it having lapsed.

Michel Rocard, Yehuda Atai and Jean-Marie Matagne are taking this opportunity to remind us that Obama’s grand design of abolishing nuclear weapons will never come to fruition unless the Middle East becomes a zone free of all weapons of mass destruction... and to clarify what conditions are needed for such a zone to come into being.

The regional daily Ouest-France is the paper with the most readers in France, covering the twelve départements of Western France where it is distributed. It publishes this article on 10 December, the same day when Obama receives his Nobel Peace Prize.


FOR A MIDDLE EAST WITHOUT WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION

Two years ago, we issued an appeal to Europeans to prevent war against Iran.(1) We are pleased to see that after that appeal (even if it played no role), the "pre-emptive war" which was then seriously threatened against Iran did not take place. That possibility is not yet totally ruled out - the "Iran question" has yet to receive a diplomatic solution in an international context, and indeed such a solution, which we desire, seems to be moving further out of reach. Yet we must still have hope, given the major change in international prospects for nuclear disarmament and non-proliferation that has occurred since Barack Obama became President of the USA.

On 13 October, the Nobel Committee awarded Obama the Nobel Peace Prize, "for his extraordinary efforts to strengthen international diplomacy and cooperation between peoples. The Committee has attached special importance to Obama’s vision of and work for a world without nuclear weapons". "Obama has as President created a new climate in international politics. Multilateral diplomacy has regained a central position, with emphasis on the role that the United Nations and other international institutions can play."

The prize-winner, however, recognised that he did not deserve it for what he had already managed to do for peace, but rather for the objectives that he was proposing to the international community. Concerning nuclear disarmament and non-proliferation, he remarked: "Some of the work confronting us will not be completed during my presidency. Some, like the elimination of nuclear weapons, may not be completed in my lifetime..." Concerning the Middle East, he emphasised: "We must all do our part to resolve conflicts that have caused so much pain and hardship over so many years [... and to uphold] the rights of all Israelis and Palestinians to live in peace and security in nations of their own."

Those two objectives: a world without nuclear weapons, and a Middle East at last experiencing a just and durable peace, are closely linked. It is clear that Israel will always refuse to eliminate its own nuclear weapons (generally estimated at at least 200 warheads) as long as its security and permanent survival are not assured. Clearly, that security and survival will continue to be threatened as long as the Israel-Palestine question is not resolved to the satisfaction of both parties, and as long as the questions of Golan and Lebanon are not also resolved. Similarly, Iran will always be suspected, rightly or wrongly, of wanting to obtain nuclear weapons as long as the Israelis retain theirs, and of desiring the disappearance of Israel as long as Israel is not universally recognised as existing within certain frontiers (a priori, those of 1967) agreed to by the United Nations and by all Israel’s neighbours, including the Palestinians. The Palestinians have a right to their own state, a sovereign, independent, viable state, which should exist until such time as the two parties agree, maybe one day, on an Israelo-Palestinian federation or confederation, which might be multi-religious or (even better) secular.

Whatever form it takes, an overall agreement of all the concerned parties is what must be sought. Multilateral negotiations, likely preceded by bilateral or plurilateral consultations, ought to achieve this end. The objective must be to resolve, through mutually acceptable compromises, the numerous concrete problems that exist, from the precise location of frontiers to the management of fresh water or of the oceans. But negotiations must also and above all aim at establishing a Middle East without any weapons of mass destruction, whether they be nuclear, biological, chemical, radioactive or new-technology weapons. That will be the Middle East’s precious and indispensable contribution to building a world of peace, cooperation and mutual understanding, freed from the threat of nuclear annihilation. The ball is in the court of Israel and the USA, just as much as it is in Iran’s.

Paris, Tel-Aviv and Saintes

Michel Rocard, former French Prime minister, MEP, ambassador for the Poles

Yehuda Atai, publisher and editor of the World of the Bible, is a co-founder of the Israeli Committee for a Middle East without nuclear, biological or chemical weapons

Jean-Marie Matagne, Dr in Philosophy, president of ACDN (Action des Citoyens pour le Désarmement Nucléaire)


(1) Published in Libération, 16 November 2007 and on ACDN Website. That appeal received widespread support (see the list of first signatories) and thousands of hits from francophone and anglophone websurfers.


L'argent est le nerf de la paix ! ACDN vous remercie de lui faire un DON

Other versions
print Printable version
pdfPDF Version


Share through social networks

Also in this section

Flame of Hope
Letter by organisations worlwide on operating status of nuclear weapons systems
War crimes in Gaza - the data on depleted uranium
The team of "Energy Challenge" made landfall at Sainte Anne de la Martinique
Saintes commemorates the 70th anniversary of the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki
Gathering for a Livable Nuclear-Free World: Final Declaration
Direct from New York: the UN Conference for a Treaty to Ban Nuclear Weapons
Manifesto for a Referendum On France’s Participation in the Abolition of Nuclear Weapons
Nuclear Dangers in Ukraine Crisis
Should you commit suicide? Surely not. But stop obeying!

navigation motscles

Barack Obama
The "Peace President" Wants To Keep America’s Nukes
Nuclear Posture Review: Rhetoric vs. Reality
Democratic Nominee Barack Obama on Arms Control
President Obama: "The United States will take concrete steps toward a world without nuclear weapons"
Remarks by the President at the Acceptance of the Nobel Peace Prize
Worldwide nuclear disarmament is the only response to anarchic proliferation
A Blow to Nuclear Power in Chicago
Obama set to reject ‘nuclear posture’ on eve of Start deal with Russia
Letter to President Obama
IRAN
No to civil and military nuclearism!
The fallout from an attack on Iran would be devastating
Israelis consider attack on Iran
IRAN : International Rally in Saintes - last chance for peace and nuclear disarmament?
Report on Iran’s Nuclear Programme Sent to UN Security Council
Israel asked US for green light to bomb nuclear sites in Iran
Russian Military Sources Warn Attack on Iran 6 April
Leading Americans Ask U.S. Military to Refuse Orders to Attack Iran
Iran reaffirms that it has no intention of obtaining nuclear weapons.
The solution exists, it just has to be seized!
ISRAEL
In Gaza, Genocide by Depleted Uranium has begun
Israel’s Nuclear Weapons - the definitive proof
"Israel will not lower its guard." Nor will Bush and Sarkozy.
Dennis Ross tells ’Post’ why Obama
Gaza War Crimes: Israeli Government Contradicts its Own "Self-Defense" Argument
Goldstone Report: Human Rights in Palestine
Israelis Attack Humanitarian Aid to Gaza
Israel did use Depleted Uranium weapons in the Gaza Strip
Abraham Serfaty has died - and Mordechai Vanunu is still trapped in Israel
The death-cult
Nuclear disarmament
President Sarkozy is ready to support the "bombing of Iran"...
Ten Steps Toward a Nuclear-Free World
The Nuclear Issue: Disarm and Live
Democracy, Disarmament, and the Rule of Law
In full: Brown’s nuclear speech
First Minister Alex Salmond wants Scotland, UK and the World rid of nuclear weapons
Good News from Russia: nuclear disarmament progressing... unintentionally!
A World Free of Nuclear Weapons
India Abandons Global Nuclear Disarmament
OPEN LETTER TO PRESIDENT CHIRAC
USA
Barack Obama undertakes to work for the abolition of nuclear weapons
Robert Gates: Nuclear Weapons and Deterrence in the 21st Century
US Economy: Rudderless and Reeling From Direct Hits

visites :  945640

Home | Contact | Site Map | Admin |

Site powered by SPIP
design et fonction Easter-Eggs